| c1740 | Philip Glonninger |
| 1759 | John Nissley |
| 1782 | Abraham Nissley |
| 1800 | Joseph & Mary Horst |
| 1813 | Current mill built |
| 1864 | Abraham Nissley |
| 1899 | Peter Gish |
| c1920 | Phares C. Miller |
| 1987 | Converted to apartments |
| 1994 | Single Residence |
| 2004 | Jon Kimmel |
The mill is located at 1347 Stone Mill Drive, Elizabethtown, PA.
| Built | 1813 |
| Structure | 3.5 Story Stone |
| Water Source | Conoy Creek |
| Township | West Donegal |
| Type | Flour/Grist |
| Headrace | 1,300 feet |
| Tailrace | 100 feet |
| Dam Height | 5.5 feet |
| Power | 1 Overshot |
| Capacity | 25 bbl / day |