| c1734 | Emanuel Hare |
| 1793 | George Withers |
| 1796 | Michael Withers |
| 1815 | New mill built |
| 1843 | George Lefever |
| 1846 | Current mill built by George & Suzanna Lefever |
| 1864 | Jacob H. Zercher |
| 1875 | J. Harnish |
| 1894 | H. F. Haverstick |
| 1899 | Mrs. H. F. Haverstick |
| 1900 | Harold Hunsicker |
| 1905 | Turbines installed |
| 1939 | J. Lloyd Sheaffer |
| 1946 | Reid Sheaffer |
| c1962 | Lancaster Milling Company |
| 1972 | Damaged by Hurricane Agnes Milling ceased |
| 1980 | Converted to generate electricity by Roy and Helen Wagner |
| 1986 | Gerald Wagner |
| 1996 | John and Karen Hoffmeister |
| 2002 | Dam collapsed |
| 2017 | Converted to private residence |
The mill has been serving as a private residence since 2017.
The mill is located at 914 Lime Valley Road, Willow Street, PA.
| Built | 1846 |
| Structure | 3.5 Story Stone |
| Water Source | Pequea Creek |
| Township | West Lampeter |
| Type | Flour/Grist/Saw/Cider |
| Headrace | 1,300 feet |
| Tailrace | 100 feet |
| Dam Height | 6 feet |
| Power | 3 Turbines |
| Capacity | 75 bbl / day |
